Ruben Zondervan

The Paradox of Proximity

On what I write, what I don't, and the price of being involved.

Recently, I realised that the closer you get to public decision-making, the greater your influence on those decisions, but the less freedom you have to write publicly about them.

This is neither a surprising insight nor an intellectual breakthrough. It was just the outcome of pondering whether or not I could publish a text I was writing. The actual answer was no, I could not publish that text, and that was not the first time I had reached that conclusion. Call it restraint, self-censorship, or just a consequence of my profession. I prefer the latter.

Writing about governance, public policy, and the energy transition, as well as some random other issues, has always been part of my professional and intellectual life. My writing is not separate from my work. Much of my thinking develops through the tension between practical professional experience and broader questions and curiosity about the issues I work on. But professional roles influence what can reasonably be said in public, be it in long form in a blog post or article, or in short form on social media.

In this text, I reflect on the double constraints on writing that apply to me as a public-sector consultant and interim manager in the public sector.

The Constraints of Public Responsibility

In the Netherlands, as in many other countries, civil servants retain their constitutional right to freedom of expression, including the right to criticise government policies. However, the Civil Servants Act restricts this freedom when public statements could undermine the performance of their duties or the functioning of the public service. Whether a statement crosses that line depends on its political sensitivity, its connection to professional responsibilities, and how it is expressed. Criticism is therefore not prohibited, and certainly not merely writing about it, but the closer the subject is to one's responsibilities, the more carefully that freedom must be exercised.

The more senior one is in the bureaucracy, the more likely statements are to approach these boundaries. Senior officials have greater responsibility for public decisions, institutional priorities, and translating political ambitions into practice, alongside a stronger obligation to serve the elected administration and maintain public confidence. Even general political commentary may thus be interpreted through the lens of one's professional position.

In my assignments as an interim manager in the public sector, now at a certain level of seniority, I am bound by these rules, even though I am not technically a civil servant.

The Constraints of Commercial Dependence

My work is not just interim management but also advisory work for the public sector as an employee of a commercial consultancy company. This comes with its own restrictions. As a consultant, one generally has greater freedom to write about or even criticise politics, policies, and institutional shortcomings. Actually, that is often what we are supposed to do in our reports (although those are usually confidential). However, under Dutch employment law, employees have a duty to act as good employees, while confidentiality obligations and commercial interests may further restrict public statements.

For consultants, these restrictions arise particularly from client relationships. Public criticism of a client, in my case always a public institution, may damage trust and jeopardise new contracts. Criticism of the advisory sector itself, or of governments' dependence on consultants, may also conflict with the employer's commercial interests. At the same time, independent thinking and critical analysis can be professional assets (often labelled as "thought leadership").

The Consultant's Double Restriction

My current position, working within local government through a commercial advisory company, means that both sets of restrictions apply simultaneously. That severely limits what I can write about, including topics I am particularly interested in. However, this double role also puts me in a position to make a difference on precisely the issues I am interested in. Thus, the freedom to criticise is inversely related to the power to change what is being criticised. (Also not a groundbreaking insight but an interesting complement to the speaking truth to power mantra I preached when still working in research management and science-policy.)

To Write or Not to Write

In practice, this means making choices about what I can and cannot write. I try to distinguish between the broader issues that interest me and the specific situations I encounter in my work. I can write about institutional shortcomings, political choices, or the challenges of the energy transition without discussing the organisations, people, or decisions I am directly involved with. Sometimes that means taking a more abstract perspective, sometimes postponing a text, and sometimes simply not publishing it.

Adding a disclaimer that the opinions expressed are entirely my own and do not represent those of my employer or clients does not really solve this. Readers will still interpret what I write in light of what I do, and a disclaimer does not remove my professional responsibilities.

Oddly enough, short statements on social media seem to carry less weight than longer, more carefully argued texts. A quick, sometimes provocative remark on social media appears to attract less professional scrutiny than a nuanced blog post making essentially the same argument. Perhaps that is because the latter looks more deliberate, even though the former may reach a much larger audience. It is a strange distinction. Or have we become so accustomed to social media crap that considered writing has become something unusual?

Whatever the reason, it adds another consideration to the question of what I can and cannot publish. This is not always convenient. Much of what I find interesting enough to write about comes directly from my professional experience. And the more relevant and concrete an observation is, the more likely it is to resonate with readers and the more likely it is to touch on something I should not discuss publicly. I do not necessarily consider this a bad thing. Discretion is part of my profession.

So I will continue writing, although not about everything I would like to write about, and not always when I would like to write it. There is, of course, a certain irony in writing about why I sometimes cannot write.

#randomramblings